Muncie Herald, May 3, 1897
PROBABLY A FAKE
Another report about Mary McCullum, the missing Brookville girl
It has been reported that Mary McCullum, the missing Brookville girl, has been seen in Muncie and departed for parts unknown a few days ago when her identity was discovered.
The report further states that the girl who gave her name as Emma DeBurgess, applied for and secured a position with one of the first families in Muncie and then disappeared when the lady she worked for discovered that she was the missing girl from Brookville.
An investigation today failed to throw any light on the subject. The Cincinnati Enquirer this morning prints a story from the Muncie correspondent which implicates in a way a Muncie merchant.
It is supposed that the story is a fake as the Enquirer correspondent is noted for such work.
The correspondent says the Muncie police are at work on the case. This statement is denied by Superintendent Baldwin.
Notes: Mary was 17 when she hopped a train for Cincinnati rather than go to school.
Cincinnati Post in June reported that she had gone to Europe to join a theatrical troupe. Later the Post claimed she was possibly in Dayton, Ohio, or possibly Andersonville.
In 1899, Cincinnati papers said she was positively seen in the city in February. She was also seen in Cleveland and possibly Hamilton, Ohio. Or Indianapolis, and possibly Elwood or Kokomo.
In 1900, somebody in Alderson, W. Va., saw a girl who looked a lot like Mary.
In 1902, the Andersonville Herald said a woman called Effie Dague was really Mary McCullum, who was still missing. Effie said that was a lie.
And ... that was all there was.
Same paper, March 4, 1904
Farmer's Strange Disappearance
Brookville -- James Hollingsworth has mysteriously disappeared. Two years ago he married, purchased a farm and has lived harmoniously and prosperously.
Monday morning, he left his wife and three-months-old baby to come to Brookville to buy some stock. He did not return and has not since been seen or heard from by the family.
Brookville Democrat, May 5, 1904
James Hollingsworth, who mysteriously disappeared from his home near Blue Creek post office on Feb. 29, put in an appearance here Wednesday morning.